A New VUE on Driving: Week Two
Saturn VUE Hybrid: Image source: BusinessWeek.com
Last week, I gave you some of my initial impressions of the Saturn VUE hybrid that GM loaned me to test out for a few weeks. On Tuesday, I turned the keys back over to the company that handles press cars for GM. I enjoyed my time giving the vehicle a spin, and look forward to the release of the 2008 model, which will incorporate the "dual mode" hybrid system that GM created in partnership with DaimlerChrysler and BMW.
I mention the release of the new version because it occured to me this past week that the 2007 VUE Hybrid, while an impressive vehicle, is a "mild hybrid": the electric engine helps power the gasoline motor so it doesn't burn as much fuel, and keeps systems operating when the gas engine shuts down at a full stop. This is helpful in terms of achieving higher fuel efficiency than the standard model (and the VUE Hybrid does get the best highway gas mileage of any SUV); the dual mode system (which will also be available in the Chevy Tahoe and the GMC Yukon) will be much more similar to a full hybrid like the Toyota Prius. The dual mode system will include:
- Engine off at idle
- Low speed electric-only propulsion
- Electric boosting during brisk acceleration, climbing steep grades or towing
- Cutting off fuel to the engine during vehicle deceleration
- Regenerative braking
- Engine speed and load control
I bring all of this up to say that I think the '08 model will be worth waiting for. According to GM, these features will increase fuel efficiency by 45%, making the VUE competitive on gas mileage with many smaller cars. And, of course, GM has also promised a plug-in model in the near future (though the company has not specified a date for it).
The '07 Model: Week 2
All of this probably sounds like I'm not that impressed with the current model VUE hybrid. That's not the case, though: it certainly did all of the things I needed it to do. When I did get it out on the highway (unfortunately, only for relatively short distances), it picked up and handled fine. It was definitely nice to have a vehicle with some room for carrying items: don't know how I'd have gotten the new crate for my big puppy home without it.
The Charge Assist Gauge in the VUE Hybrid: Image Source: AllWorldCars.comMore importantly, though, the current VUE model does sip gas compared to other SUVs. I don't have exact figures, as I never had to put any gas in it while I had it. I used roughly a half-tank of gas doing my normal driving, plus a few extra trips such as picking my wife up at the airport.
With that said, I don't think this is the vehicle for someone who drives like I do: primarily running errands and such. The VUE Hybrid is kind of unique among hybrids in that its gas mileage figures parallel those of traditional vehicles: it gets better mileage on the highway than in town. As such, I'd recommend it to someone who does more highway driving than I do. If you commute long distances, for instance, this is probably a better choice than a full hybrid. Unless you need the extra space, though, a smaller, high-mileage car may be your best bet in terms of fuel efficiency and sticker price. If you're a traveller, this may be the exact vehicle you want, as it combines plenty of storage space with good highway fuel efficiency. It's also quite reasonably priced for an SUV: just under $23,000.
I enjoyed driving the VUE hybrid for a couple of weeks, and am now having to get used to my own car again. We'd be really interested in hearing from anyone who does own one of these vehicles — is your own experience similar to mine?


May 31st, 2007 at 2:24 pm
I really like the color of the one in the picture. And it's good to see the improving quality and technology of a made in the USofA car.
June 3rd, 2007 at 4:58 am
A delightfully simple, reliable, flexible and very useful vehicle at a bargin price and excellent fuel mileage. It drives well, without excitement or trauma. It feels well planted and safe.
I like the simple, rather plain lines, certainly not ostentaious and honest look.The interior is roomy and comfortable with a suprisingly high quality, almost elegant look.
Overall, I am impressed enough to buy one as early as next week.
Good show Saturn.
June 4th, 2007 at 2:44 pm
Jeff, the two-mode hybrid Vue won’t be available until the middle of 2008 as a 2009 model. For 2008 the Vue keeps the same mild hybrid system which will remain a lower cost option even after the two-mode is available. The two-mode system launches on the Tahoe/Yukon this fall followed by the pickups and Escalade early next year and then the Vue.
June 4th, 2007 at 2:55 pm
Thanks for the correction, Sam… I’ll get that fixed.
_______________________________________
Jeff McIntire-Strasburg
Senior Editor
Green Options
jeff@greenoptions.com
June 7th, 2007 at 8:43 pm
Not to rain on the hybrid party, but I find it rather alarming that companies are developing SUV hybrids. Surely a lighter car will make for a more efficient vehicle, right? Escalade, VUE, and Tahoe, I am afraid to say are monstrous, militant vehicles. Couldn't we have some hybrid mini tiny cars out there?
As far as technology, I am disheartened by the baby steps car manufacturers are taking. The film, "Who Killed the Electric Car?" shows us that plug-in electric cars were ready for the road almost twenty years ago, and car companies pulled the plug. Watch the movie to see a document of the slow and painful death of the electric car. See how it was buried alive. Now,because consumer markets are demanding it, we are seeing more hybrid vehicles, but mild hybrid engines, as opposed to two-mode engines, as opposed to plug-in hybrids, as opposed to full electric. The technology exists, there is no reason to keep buyers waiting. Jeff alludes to this by noting that the dual mode engine is worth the wait. Let's not give auto makers an easy out.